It's astonishing to realise just how many utterly wonderful songs Dylan has been responsible for. And when you hear other people do them you realise afresh just how great they are as pieces in themselves as opposed to hearing them as vehicles for the Bobster's astonishing performances. (I suppose equally stunning is the attendant realisation of how much has had to be left off. No one, for example, had the temerity to cover Tangled Up In Blue, hardly surprisingly.)
Even though there are a few clunkers on board in terms of lacklustre performances - no names, no packdrill, I'm far too charitable for that - even these are somehow acceptable since, at the very least, you can run through the original in your mind as they are being wrecked, with a better understanding of why they worked originally. But I reckon at least half the cuts are downright inspired, whilst most are more than acceptable. For example, to my delighted surprise Miley Cyrus does a nice job on You're Gonna Make Me Lonesome When You Go, reminding me (as if I needed it) of just how fragilely perfect the lyric is.
I'd be jabbering on forever if I tried to do justice to the inspired stuff, but I'll just mention
And just think, by buying the set you're donating to everybody's favourite human rights group. Blimey.
No comments:
Post a Comment